Skip to content
LSLab

How Do Closed-Loop and Open-Loop Recycling Differ?

  • Starter
  • Article
  • Ages 10+
  • 6 min read
Used aluminum cans on a sorting conveyor beside a compacted bale at a recycling facility.

Closed-loop recycling returns used material to feedstock for making the same kind of product, with the aim of preserving its properties from one cycle to the next. Open-loop recycling makes a different material, usually of lower grade and purity, which ends up as waste. The difference is whether the material can come back into the loop of use.

Contents
A closed loop comes back to its start with the material as before; an open loop runs one way, the material shrinking until it ends as a heap of waste.
  • Closed-loop frame (left)
  • Four equal squares (material kept as it was)
  • Green arrows joined into a circle
  • Open-loop frame (right)
  • Row of squares getting smaller
  • Triangular heap at the end (waste)

What you will learn

Before you start

You only need to know that recycling means using material from discarded goods again. Other terms are explained as they come up.

How does open-loop recycling work?

In an open loop the material goes one way and ends as waste. Open-loop recycling basically means that a material is not recycled indefinitely and in the end drops out of the loop of use and becomes waste. That recycling loop produces another material, typically of lower grade and purity than the original.

One example: recycling polyester soda bottles gives polymer fibres, which may be supplied to a carpet maker. But carpet is not easily recyclable because it is a more complex product. When a material lives a few lives but becomes less usable, pure or safe on its way to the landfill, it is often called downcycling.

An open loop still helps. It postpones disposal and slows the extraction of new resources, but is not an ultimate solution to the problem.

Bottle to fibre, fibre to carpet, carpet to waste: at each step the material is less reusable.
  • Bottle (bottle shape with a neck)
  • Polymer fibres (three wavy lines)
  • Carpet (striped rectangle)
  • Landfill (triangular heap)
  • Steps in order (arrows)
  • Reusability falling (four columns getting shorter)

What is different about closed-loop recycling?

In a closed loop the material returns to make the same product. It is the more sustainable concept: in an ideal closed loop, a material can be recycled indefinitely without its properties degrading. The used product is converted back to raw material, so the same product can be made again and again.

The example is the soda can: almost all recycled aluminium from soda cans is suitable for making the same cans again.

There is one more condition. In a closed loop contaminants or toxins must not accumulate over many cycles, since they can make the secondary product less safe. The other part of the closed loop is biodegradable disposal: anything that cannot be recycled or is a manufacturing by-product should return to the environment without harm.

What decides which loop a material takes?

The purity of the material and the design of the product. To reuse materials in the same or new products, they have to be separated in a pure form. How recyclable a product is is often related to its design.

These two points connect to the differences above. An open loop usually gives a material of lower purity; a closed loop requires that contaminants do not build up.

If contaminants are not removed they build up with each pass: the more times round, the more red dots.
  • Three stages of the loop (three rectangles)
  • Arrows joined into a loop
  • Contaminants (red dots increasing)

Real-world example

Think of a soda bottle and an aluminium can. A polyester bottle turned into carpet fibre is an open loop: carpet is hard to recycle, so the material drifts toward waste. An aluminium can made into the same cans again is a closed loop.

Common misunderstandings

All recycling is closed-loop. Many cases only postpone waste: the material loses quality and cannot return to the original process.

An open loop is useless. It postpones disposal and slows the extraction of new resources, even though it is not an ultimate solution.

A closed loop needs no safety thinking. Contaminants that accumulate over many cycles can make the secondary product less safe.

Frequently asked questions

What is downcycling?

It is when a material lives a few lives but becomes less usable, pure or safe on its way to the landfill.

Which loop does an aluminium can belong to?

Almost all recycled aluminium from soda cans is suitable for making the same cans again, so it is an example of a closed loop.

Why is carpet hard to recycle?

Carpet is not easily recyclable because it is a more complex product.

Summary

  • A closed loop returns to make the same product without the material degrading; an open loop makes a different, lesser material.
  • An open loop postpones waste and slows new extraction, but the material ends up as waste.
  • Purity, contaminants and product design decide which loop a material takes.

Terms in this article

English and Vietnamese terms, with the meanings used here. Hover, tap or Tab to a term with a dotted underline for an explanation as you read.

closed-loop recyclingtái chế vòng kín
Recycling that turns used material back into raw material to make the same kind of product again and again without losing its properties.
open-loop recyclingtái chế vòng hở
Recycling that makes a different, usually lower-grade material, which ends up as waste in the long run.
downcyclingtái chế hạ cấp
Recycling in which a material lives a few lives but becomes less and less usable, pure or safe.
contaminanttạp chất
A substance mixed into recycled material; if it builds up over many cycles it can make the product less safe.
purityđộ tinh sạch
How free a material is of anything else; needed to reuse it in the same or a new product.

This article is not marked as viewed

Spotted something wrong or unsafe?

Tell the administrator by email. The message already has the article title and address.

Report this article
  • A sorting conveyor directing paper, plastic bottles and metal cans toward recovery channels.
    Starter

    How Is Waste Sorted?

    Follow sorting from the point of disposal to a materials recovery facility, and understand why local acceptance rules come before bin choice.

    6 min read
  • Clean cardboard, a glass jar, a plastic bottle and an aluminium can arranged on a light surface.
    Starter

    Which Materials Can Be Recycled?

    Compare paper, plastic, glass and aluminium, distinguishing technical recyclability from acceptance by a local collection programme.

    5 min read
  • A cloth grocery tote, metal bottle and glass jar beside a recycling caddy with cans and paper.
    Starter

    How Do Reduction, Reuse and Recycling Differ?

    Reduction prevents waste, reuse keeps an item in use and recycling turns used items into raw materials. See how the three differ and which comes first.

    5 min read
  • Blue and grey kitchen bins: loose bottles and dry paper in the blue bin, tied rubbish bags in the grey bin and a clean bottle between them.
    Starter

    What Does Source Separation Contribute?

    Source separation directs recyclables into the right collection route. See why misplaced items may be lost and why local rules matter.

    5 min read
See all articles of the topic

Sources

These sources are written for older readers. If they feel hard, read them with an adult.